Among cash advance apps like Cleo, EarnIn is the cheapest way to get $100 in minutes today: a $5.99 Lightning Speed fee and no membership. Dave’s fee is lower at $5, but Dave adds a membership of up to $5 a month, and its fee applies even if you wait. That is the key difference: EarnIn, Brigit, Cleo and MoneyLion (to its own account) deliver free if you can wait a few days; Dave never does.

Updated November 9, 2026: we rechecked every fee, limit, delivery time and regulator case below against each company’s own pages, SEC filings and court or regulator records. MoneyLion’s instant fee, EarnIn’s daily limit and Dave’s membership price changed; Brigit, Dave and MoneyLion face new state cases.

This guide compares Dave, EarnIn, Brigit and MoneyLion on their own fee pages, terms and help centers, plus the regulator cases each one has faced. Cleo is the baseline; our full Cleo review covers its plans, express fee and FTC settlement in detail.

Cleo vs Dave vs Brigit: head to head

Cleo Dave Brigit
Monthly fee $5.99 (Plus), $8.99 (Pro), $14.99 (Builder); an advance without a plan is possible by email Up to $5; $3 for members who joined since June 2025 $8.99 (Plus) or $15.99 (Premium); an advance without a plan is possible by email
Advance range $20 to $250 ($20 to $100 for first-time users); up to $500 on Builder with direct deposit $25 to $500 $25 to $500 ($25 to $250 in Maine)
Instant fee on $100 Somewhere in $4.49 to $14.99; Cleo shows the exact fee only in the app $5 to Dave Checking; $6.50 to an outside debit card $0.99 to $5.99 on Plus (exact fee in the app); $0 on Premium
Standard delivery Free, 3 to 4 days ACH to an outside bank in 2 to 3 business days, but the $5 fee still applies Free, 1 to 3 days
Credit check No No No
If repayment fails No obligation to repay; Cleo keeps retrying (smaller amounts if you opted in) and can refuse new advances Dave takes partial amounts and retries; no late fees, no credit impact; account closed after 60 days negative No obligation to repay; partial debits and retries; no collections or credit reporting; new advances suspended

Sources: Cleo pricing, terms, request help page, repayment help page and credit check statement; Dave fees, membership, 10-Q, extensions and ExtraCash agreement; Brigit pricing, delivery, Instant Cash and terms. All checked November 9, 2026.

Cash advance apps like Cleo at a glance

App Monthly fee Advance range Instant delivery fee Free option
Cleo $5.99 (Plus) to $14.99 (Builder) $20 to $250; up to $500 on Builder $4.49 to $14.99 Standard delivery, 3 to 4 days
Dave Up to $5 $25 to $500 5% of the amount, $5 minimum, plus 1.5% to an outside debit card None: ACH to an outside bank is free to send, but the 5% fee still applies
EarnIn None required; tips optional Up to $200 a day ($150 in Maryland), $1,000 a pay period $3.99 to $8.99 by amount Standard speed, $0, 1 to 2 business days
Brigit $8.99 (Plus) or $15.99 (Premium) $25 to $500 ($25 to $250 in Maine) $0.99 to $5.99 on Plus; free on Premium Standard delivery, 1 to 3 days
MoneyLion None required for Instacash Up to $500; MoneyLion says up to $1,000 with a limit increase 7.5% of the advance to MoneyLion Spend (capped at $14.99); 9% to an outside account Standard delivery to MoneyLion Spend only

Sources: Cleo terms and pricing; Dave and Dave fee help page; EarnIn Cash Out, EarnIn Max help page and EarnIn fees; Brigit pricing and terms; MoneyLion Instacash and pricing. All checked November 9, 2026.

The headline maximums are ceilings, not what most people get. Dave says “few qualify for $500” (Dave Help), EarnIn says qualified new members get an $85 daily limit on average (EarnIn), and Brigit says its average advance from February 2018 to July 2025 was $73 (Brigit Help). Two of these companies, Brigit and Dave, have been sued by the federal government over exactly that gap between the advertised amount and the real one (details below).

What a $100 advance costs at each app

The fee for one $100 advance delivered in minutes, from each app’s published schedule, and what it equals as an annual rate if repaid in 14 days. Membership is listed separately and is not in the rate.

App Instant fee on $100 Annual rate if repaid in 14 days Membership Notes
Cleo $4.49 to $14.99 (exact fee in the app) 117.1% to 390.8% $5.99 a month (Plus) Standard delivery free
Dave $5 to Dave Checking; $6.50 to an outside debit card 130.4%; 169.5% Up to $5 a month The 5% fee ($5 minimum) applies even to free-speed transfers
EarnIn $5.99 156.2% None Tips optional; different pricing in Indiana, Florida, Texas, Ohio, Illinois and Pennsylvania
Brigit $0.99 to $5.99 on Plus (exact fee in the app) 25.8% to 156.2% $8.99 a month (Plus) Premium ($15.99) includes free express delivery
MoneyLion $7.50 to MoneyLion Spend; $9 to an outside account 195.5%; 234.6% None Standard delivery free to MoneyLion Spend only

How we got the numbers: Dave charges 5% (minimum $5) plus 1.5% to an outside debit card (Dave); EarnIn charges $5.99 for $75.01 to $150 (EarnIn); MoneyLion charges 7.5% to Spend and 9% elsewhere (MoneyLion); Brigit and Cleo publish only a range (Brigit terms; Cleo pricing).

What that is as an annual rate. None of these apps charges interest, so none quotes an APR. But a flat fee on a short advance works out to a high rate. The formula is:

APR equivalent = (fee ÷ amount advanced) × (365 ÷ days until repayment) × 100

Worked example: Dave’s $5 fee on a $100 advance to Dave Checking, repaid in 14 days, is (5 ÷ 100) × (365 ÷ 14) × 100 = 130.4% a year (Dave fee). The other rates in the table use the same formula. The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) put the APR of a typical employer-partnered earned wage advance at 109.5% in 2024, and found expedite fees of $1 to $5.99, averaging $3.18 (CFPB).

The pattern matters more than one advance. The CFPB found workers took an average of 27 advances a year (CFPB). Twenty-seven $5.99 fees is $161.73 a year, before membership.

Dave ExtraCash

What it is. Dave’s advance is called ExtraCash. Legally, ExtraCash is an overdraft on a separate ExtraCash account, not a loan: the agreement says a negative balance is “payable immediately upon demand” (Dave ExtraCash agreement), and Dave advertises no interest, no credit check and no late fees (Dave).

Amounts. $25 to $500, “typically authorized within 5 minutes,” judged on “180+ data points” from your bank data (Dave). On-time repayment, a positive balance and recurring deposits help, and you cannot take more while a balance is outstanding (Dave Help).

Fees. Dave replaced tips and express fees with a flat overdraft fee, completed for all members in February 2025, when it described the fee as 5% with a $5 minimum and a $15 cap (Dave investor relations). Dave’s third-quarter 2026 10-Q says it “began removing” that cap during the second quarter of 2026 “for certain Member cohorts” (Dave 10-Q). Its help page lists “5% of the transfer (minimum $5),” no express fee to Dave Checking, 1.5% to an outside debit card within an hour, and no express fee for ACH to an outside bank in 2 to 3 business days (Dave Help). Without a cap, 5% of a $400 advance is $20.

The membership is “up to $5” a month and covers ExtraCash, budgeting tools and income features; you can cancel in Membership settings, effective at the end of the cycle (Dave Help). The same 10-Q says Dave raised the monthly membership fee from $1 to $3 for new members in June 2025, with earlier members kept at their old rate (Dave 10-Q).

Repayment. Dave collects from your connected bank account “around your next payday, or the nearest Friday,” and takes partial amounts if the full balance is not there (Dave Help). Dave says “late settlements won’t add late fees or affect your credit” (Dave Help). The agreement says Dave’s bank will close the ExtraCash account after 60 or more calendar days negative (Dave ExtraCash agreement).

The federal case. The FTC sued Dave in November 2024, and on December 30, 2024 the Justice Department filed an amended complaint that added CEO Jason Wilk. It alleges Dave “very rarely” offered anywhere near the advertised $500, hid an express fee, misused tips and made the membership hard to cancel (DOJ). Dave called the case “government overreach” (Dave). The case is still open: the court denied Dave’s motion to dismiss on September 12, 2025, Dave answered on October 10, 2025, and Dave reports a $10.0 million accrual for legal contingencies as of September 30, 2026 (Dave 10-Q; court docket).

Local cases. The filing also reports suits over ExtraCash by Baltimore (filed December 30, 2025; Dave moved to dismiss on October 8, 2026) and by the Montgomery County, Pennsylvania district attorney (filed September 28, 2026) (Dave 10-Q).

EarnIn Cash Out

What it is. EarnIn, run by Activehours, Inc., lets you take part of pay you have already earned before payday. It is the only one of the four with no subscription at all: “No interest, no credit check, no mandatory fees” (EarnIn).

Amounts and requirements. Up to $1,000 per pay period and now up to $200 a day, or $150 in Maryland (EarnIn Help); new members average $85 a day. You need a regular pay schedule, at least $320 per pay period (EarnIn), a US checking account (not prepaid or savings) and US residence (EarnIn Help). Among the factors EarnIn lists for raising your limit is “using fewer cash advance apps” (EarnIn Help).

Fees. Standard speed is $0 and generally arrives in 1 to 2 business days (EarnIn Cash Out User Agreement). Lightning Speed costs $3.99 for $75 or less, $5.99 for $75.01 to $150 and $8.99 above $150; Early Pay costs $2.99 (EarnIn fees, updated November 2, 2026). Indiana, Florida, Texas, Ohio, Illinois and Pennsylvania have different pricing, and Wisconsin and Colorado customers may see a no-tip model with its own fees. A newer option, Cash Out Link, adds a $1.99 service fee per transfer (EarnIn Help). The “starting at just $3.99” on the product page is the lowest tier, not the price for most amounts (EarnIn).

Tips are optional, do not affect your limit, and EarnIn’s agreement says it will refund a tip if you ask within 30 days of repayment (EarnIn Cash Out User Agreement). Keep that in mind when the app suggests one: a $5 tip on a $100 advance costs nearly as much as the $5.99 Lightning fee.

Repayment. “On your payday, EarnIn will automatically debit your linked bank account for the amount you transferred out, plus any optional tips or fees.” You can ask support to move the date, by 8 a.m. Pacific at least one business day before the debit (EarnIn Help). If a debit fails, the agreement says you have no obligation to repay, and EarnIn will not use debt collection, sell the amount to a third party or report it to a credit bureau; you just cannot take another Cash Out until the old one is paid (EarnIn Cash Out User Agreement).

State cases. Colorado’s attorney general sued EarnIn on August 27, 2026, calling its advances payday loans. The AG alleges 56,778 Coloradans paid more than $16 million in tips and Lightning Speed fees from January 2023 to July 2025, at an average APR of nearly 388%; EarnIn has not been found liable (Colorado AG). The District of Columbia’s attorney general brought a similar case in November 2024, alleging average rates above 300% against a 24% cap (DC AG). In January 2026 the DC Court of Appeals denied the attorney general’s request for a mid-case appeal of a trial-court ruling, citing the doctrine that lets a court defer a question to a regulator (DC Court of Appeals order, No. 25-DA-0016).

Brigit Instant Cash

What it is. Brigit is run by Bridge It, Inc. Upbound Group completed its purchase of Brigit on January 31, 2025 (Upbound).

Plans. The free plan has budgeting tools only. Plus, at $8.99 a month, adds Instant Cash, credit monitoring and identity theft protection. Premium, at $15.99, adds Credit Builder and free Express Delivery (Brigit Help, updated May 7, 2026). Brigit’s terms give the Plus price as “$5.99 to $9.99,” so the price you see may vary (Brigit terms, revised March 31, 2026). Both pages say you can ask for an advance without a plan by email; the help page gives the address as terms1@hellobrigit.com.

Amounts and requirements. $25 to $500, or $25 to $250 in Maine. Brigit wants a checking account at least 60 days old with a balance above $0 and at least three recurring deposits from the same source, and it uses its own 0 to 100 score instead of a credit check (Brigit). It connects to banks through Plaid, which it says covers more than 6,000 banks and credit unions (Brigit Help).

Fees and delivery. Express Delivery costs $0.99 to $5.99 for non-Premium users and “may vary based on the amount of your Advance”; Brigit does not publish the fee for each amount (Brigit terms). Express takes “2 - 20 minutes for most users”; standard delivery is free and takes 1 to 3 days (Brigit Help), though the Instant Cash page says 2 to 3 business days (Brigit).

Repayment. Brigit’s terms say Instant Cash “is not credit,” repayment “is entirely voluntary,” and Brigit will not use debt collection or report you to a credit bureau. It still debits on the due date (or a later date you pick in the app), can debit whenever money comes in, takes partial amounts and retries other authorized payment methods; unpaid advances suspend future ones (Brigit terms).

The FTC case. In November 2023, Brigit agreed to an $18 million judgment to settle FTC charges that it promised “instant” advances of up to $250 that few people got, charged 99 cents for express delivery after advertising free instant transfers, and blocked people from cancelling the $9.99 membership while an advance was open (FTC complaint; FTC order).

The Minnesota case. On June 10, 2026, Minnesota’s attorney general sued Brigit as an unlicensed payday lender, alleging APRs that “regularly exceed 300%, with some exceeding 700%,” against a 50% state cap (Minnesota AG).

Cancelling. In the app: profile icon, Preferences, My Subscription, then “Cancel & Switch to Free plan.” An open Credit Builder loan has to be closed first, and you may still be charged at the end of the billing cycle in which you cancel (Brigit Help).

MoneyLion Instacash

What it is. MoneyLion is “a financial technology company, not a bank”; its Spend deposit account is provided by Pathward, N.A., Member FDIC (MoneyLion). Gen Digital completed its purchase of MoneyLion on April 17, 2025 (Gen).

Amounts. Up to $500, and MoneyLion says you can raise your limit up to $1,000. “No interest. No credit check. No mandatory fees.” Its FAQ says there is a maximum of $100 per disbursement, so a larger amount comes in several transfers (MoneyLion). The terms add that your limit “will not exceed 50% of the Eligible Direct Deposits” and that you need recurring direct deposits to qualify (MoneyLion terms).

Fees. The biggest change since our last check. Free standard delivery now goes only to a MoneyLion Spend account (1 to 5 business days on the pricing page, typically 1 to 2 in the terms); an outside account requires Turbo, which is now a percentage (MoneyLion pricing; MoneyLion terms):

Turbo destination Fee On $100
MoneyLion Spend 7.5% of the advance, capped at $14.99 $7.50
Outside debit card or checking account 9% of the advance $9.00

The pricing page also lists Credit Builder Plus, a separate membership, at $19.99 a month; you do not need it for Instacash.

Repayment. The terms say “Instacash is not a loan” and “there is no obligation to repay,” but you cannot take a new advance until earlier ones and their Turbo fees are repaid. MoneyLion says it will not use debt collection, sell the debt or report to credit bureaus. It debits on a date tied to your direct deposit, can take partial amounts, and can use a backup payment method (MoneyLion terms; MoneyLion).

The CFPB and New York cases. The CFPB sued MoneyLion in September 2022, alleging it charged servicemembers more than the Military Lending Act allows and kept charging membership fees after people asked to cancel. A final judgment on November 24, 2025 ordered $1.75 million in consumer redress (CFPB). New York’s attorney general sued in April 2025, alleging Instacash is usurious lending and that an $8.99 fee on a two-week $100 advance equals about 234% APR (NY AG). Gen’s quarterly report filed October 29, 2026 says that case “remains pending” and that MoneyLion is defending it (Gen 10-Q).

Are these advances loans?

The apps say no, and regulators disagree with each other.

  • The apps’ position. Brigit and MoneyLion call their advances non-recourse and “not a loan”; Dave structures ExtraCash as an overdraft; EarnIn and Cleo call their products earned wage access (terms linked in each section).
  • The CFPB’s December 2025 opinion. The CFPB said “covered” earned wage access is not credit under the Truth in Lending Act if four conditions hold, including repayment through a payroll deduction and no recourse, collections or credit checks. It also said “a transfer to the provider from any of the consumer’s regular transaction accounts after the payment of wages” is not a payroll deduction (CFPB advisory opinion, Federal Register). All five apps here collect from your bank account, not through your employer’s payroll.
  • States. Colorado and the District of Columbia have sued EarnIn, Minnesota has sued Brigit, and New York has sued MoneyLion under lending laws (see above). Wisconsin licenses earned wage access providers, requires at least one no-cost option and, from April 5, 2026, caps delivery fees (Wisconsin DFI).

Whatever the label, the fee is the price of borrowing for a week or two, and should be compared as one.

How these apps compare with Cleo

  • Cheapest route if you can wait: EarnIn (no membership, free standard speed), then MoneyLion (free, but only to its Spend account). Brigit and Cleo also deliver free, but their default path to an advance is a paid plan.
  • Dave is different. Its 5% fee (minimum $5) applies whether you take the money instantly or by ACH, so there is no free speed.
  • Highest advertised amounts: EarnIn ($1,000 a pay period) and MoneyLion (up to $1,000). Starting amounts at every app are much lower.
  • Chat and budgeting: Cleo is the one built around an AI chat assistant. The others have budgeting tools but lead with the advance.
  • Regulatory history: Cleo ($17 million, 2025) and Brigit ($18 million, 2023) settled with the FTC; MoneyLion settled with the CFPB for $1.75 million. Open cases: Dave (federal, Baltimore, Pennsylvania), EarnIn (Colorado, DC), Brigit (Minnesota), MoneyLion (New York).

If you are comparing budgeting assistants rather than advances, see our guide to AI-powered financial assistants and Monarch vs YNAB.

Before you use one

  1. Pick one app. Advances from several apps can all debit your account on the same payday. EarnIn even names multiple apps as a reason your limit may stay low.
  2. Choose standard delivery when you can. At EarnIn, Brigit and Cleo it is free, and at MoneyLion it is free to a Spend account.
  3. Set tips to $0 if you do not want to pay one. They are optional at every app that offers them.
  4. Cancel memberships you are not using. Brigit, Cleo and Dave bill monthly whether or not you take an advance. Screenshot the cancellation confirmation.
  5. Watch the debit date. A failed repayment debit can trigger an overdraft or returned-payment fee from your own bank, even if the app charges nothing.
  6. If you need an advance every pay period, a nonprofit credit counselor can review your budget for free or at low cost; the CFPB explains how to find one.

These apps also connect to your bank through a data aggregator. Our privacy walkthrough of AI finance apps explains how to see and revoke that access. This guide is general information, not financial advice. More guides: AI personal finance assistants.

How we checked this

This is a documentation review: we built it from each company’s own pricing pages, terms, help center articles, investor releases and SEC filings, and from FTC, Justice Department, CFPB, Federal Register, court and state attorney general documents. The dollar and APR examples are our arithmetic from the published fee schedules. Facts checked on November 9, 2026. FTC press release pages could not be loaded during this check, so FTC facts link to the FTC’s own complaint and order documents instead.